ahrefs webmaster toolsgoogle search consolesite auditfree seo toolstechnical seo

Ahrefs Webmaster Tools vs Google Search Console: What Each Shows

Ahrefs Webmaster Tools, now called Ahrefs Free, crawls your site for 170+ issues and shows backlinks from Ahrefs' own index. Google Search Console reports what Google itself indexed and searched. What each tool shows, its limits, and why most sites should use both.

· 9 min read

Ahrefs Webmaster Tools (now renamed Ahrefs Free) and Google Search Console answer different questions, and both are free for sites you own. Ahrefs Free crawls your site with Ahrefs' own crawler, flags 170+ technical and on-page SEO issues in Site Audit, and shows your backlinks and ranking keywords from Ahrefs' index. Google Search Console reports Google's own data: which of your pages Google indexed or excluded and why, the real queries and clicks your pages got, and alerts for indexing, spam and security problems. Use Search Console as the source of truth for Google, and Ahrefs Free to find issues and links Search Console does not list.

Details below were checked on Ahrefs' and Google's own pages on November 11, 2026.

Ahrefs Webmaster Tools vs Google Search Console at a glance

Ahrefs Free (formerly Ahrefs Webmaster Tools)Google Search Console
Who runs the dataAhrefs: its own crawler and indexGoogle: its own crawling, indexing and search logs
PriceFree for websites with verified ownershipFree
Site auditSite Audit: 170+ technical and on-page issues, Health Score over timeNo crawler-style audit; reports issues Google encountered (indexing, Core Web Vitals, structured data, security)
Crawl allowance5,000 crawl credits per verified project per month (only 200-status HTML pages use credits)Not applicable; Google crawls on its own schedule
Indexing statusNot available: Ahrefs cannot see Google's indexPage indexing report, URL Inspection, request indexing
Search queries and clicksKeywords your site ranks for, from Ahrefs' database (up to 1,000 visible at once)Real queries, clicks, impressions and position from Google Search
BacklinksLinks Ahrefs found, up to 1,000 visible at once, with link type dataLinks report: tables limited to 1,000 rows, a sample of links
Web analyticsWeb Analytics, cookieless by default, including traffic from LLMsNot included
Migrations and removalsNot includedChange of Address tool; Removals (requests last about 6 months)
Competitor sitesNo (verified sites only; competitors need a paid plan)No (only properties you verify)

What Ahrefs Webmaster Tools (Ahrefs Free) does better

A real site audit. Ahrefs Site Audit crawls every page it can reach, groups 170+ issues by technical SEO category, splits them into errors, warnings and notices, and explains how to fix each. Search Console only reports problems Google happened to run into, with example URLs.

Broken links on your own site. Ahrefs lists broken links data for internal and external links. Search Console reports 404s that Google ran into, which is not the same as a crawl of every internal link.

More backlink context. Ahrefs shows domain- and page-level SEO metrics for the sites linking to you and link type data (nofollow, UGC, sponsored), with up to 1,000 backlinks visible at once.

Privacy-focused analytics. Web Analytics is included, cookieless by default, with historical graphs that include traffic from LLMs.

Ahrefs' own comparison page contrasts its "170+ SEO issues" with "a handful of issues" in Search Console. That framing is the vendor's, and it compares two different kinds of report: an audit of what Ahrefs crawled versus Google's account of what it indexed.

What Google Search Console does better

It is Google's own data. Only Search Console can tell you whether Google indexed a URL, which canonical Google selected, and which real queries your pages appeared for. Google describes it as a free service to monitor, maintain and troubleshoot your site's presence in Google Search, including confirming Google can crawl your site, fixing indexing problems and requesting re-indexing.

Indexing diagnosis. The Page indexing report and URL Inspection are the only way to see Google's reason for excluding a page, such as a duplicate without a user-selected canonical or "Crawled - currently not indexed". No third-party crawler can see that.

Real query data. The Performance report shows actual clicks and impressions from Google Search, by query, page, country and device, for date ranges you choose. Ahrefs' ranking keywords are estimates from its own database.

Site moves and urgent removals. Change of Address helps migrate your Google results from an old domain to a new one, and the Removals tool temporarily hides URLs (Google says requests last about 6 months). See old domain still showing in Google for when to use each.

Use both: a simple weekly routine

  1. Search Console, Page indexing: note any jump in excluded URLs and the reason given.
  2. Ahrefs Free, Site Audit: check new errors after a crawl, especially broken links, redirect chains and noindex pages.
  3. Cross-check: if Ahrefs flags a page as broken or noindexed, inspect it in Search Console to see whether Google is affected.
  4. Search Console, Performance: watch clicks and impressions for the pages you fixed.

Where both stop

Both are cloud services. Neither can audit a staging site or localhost before launch, Ahrefs Free cannot audit a site you cannot verify, and neither runs accessibility checks across the site or scores whether AI answer engines can retrieve and cite your pages. For those jobs, a desktop auditor such as Audra runs on your own Mac (Apple Silicon) or Windows PC, audits up to 1,000 pages per report with Lighthouse, axe-core, 14 HTML SEO checks and 8 AEO checks, and exports one scored report. It is $19 once (launch price; regular price $49, also one-time) after a free 7-day trial, and it has no backlink, keyword or field data, so it complements rather than replaces either tool. For the paid side of Ahrefs, see Audra vs Ahrefs Site Audit.

FAQ

Is Ahrefs Webmaster Tools still free?

Yes. Ahrefs Webmaster Tools is now called Ahrefs Free and is free for websites with verified ownership, on an unlimited number of verified sites. It includes Site Audit, Site Explorer and Web Analytics, with 5,000 crawl credits per verified project per month for Site Audit.

Is Ahrefs Webmaster Tools better than Google Search Console?

Neither is better overall. Ahrefs is better for crawling your site to find technical issues and for backlink context. Search Console is better, and irreplaceable, for Google's own indexing status and real search query data. Most site owners should use both.

Does Ahrefs Webmaster Tools use Google Search Console data?

Its core data comes from Ahrefs' own crawler and index, not from Google. Ahrefs plans do list Google Search Console features, but Search Console remains the only place to see Google's indexing decisions directly.

How do I verify my site in Ahrefs Webmaster Tools?

Ahrefs Free requires verified ownership of each website before Site Audit, Site Explorer and Web Analytics work on it, and you can verify an unlimited number of sites. Ahrefs' help centre explains what counts as a verified project.

What are the limits of Ahrefs Webmaster Tools?

5,000 Site Audit crawl credits per verified project per month, up to 1,000 backlinks and 1,000 keywords visible at once in Site Explorer, and no access to sites you cannot verify. Paid Ahrefs plans raise those limits and allow competitor research.

Sources