backlink analysislink buildingcompetitor researchseo workflowseo automation

Competitor Backlink Gap Analysis: A Practical Review Workflow

A practical method for turning competitor backlink overlap into a smaller, evidence-backed queue of link, content, partnership, and PR opportunities.

· 16 min read

The source workflow compares one target site with three competitors, removes duplicate referring domains, groups domains by how many competitors they link to, and then reviews links and anchors. This competitor backlink gap analysis helps SEO teams turn that raw overlap into a documented, prioritised review queue rather than treating every missing link as an outreach opportunity.

The original experiment used Ahrefs data through Monid and a coding agent. That distinction matters: the source demonstrates a useful process for collecting and comparing data, but it does not document which Ahrefs endpoints, fields, access level, or API version were used behind that setup. Teams should therefore validate their own available fields before designing a production workflow around them.

For consultants, agencies, and site owners, the practical payoff is a smaller list of prospects with an explainable reason for review. The aim is not to maximise the number of domains in an export. It is to identify pages, relationships, and content patterns that a site can pursue credibly.

Shared referring domains are only a starting point

A referring domain is a useful unit for comparison because a single domain may link to a competitor from multiple pages. However, a domain that links to two or three competitors is not automatically a valuable, relevant, or repeatable link opportunity.

The source author’s approach of grouping domains by the number of competitors they link to is a sensible way to find patterns. A three-way overlap may indicate that a publication, association, resource page, or community is active in a market. It does not establish why the links were earned or whether another site can earn a similar placement.

Consider this hypothetical payroll-software example:

  • association.example links to several vendors from a maintained member directory.
  • business-news.example covered funding announcements from several companies.
  • software-directory.example creates thin listing pages for a large number of products.
  • university.example cites several products in course materials about HR systems.

The association directory may be worth investigating if the target genuinely qualifies for membership. The business-news links may be tied to events that cannot be replicated through ordinary outreach. The directory may have little strategic value, while the university citations may point to a need for better educational material rather than a request for a direct link.

Overlap identifies a set of domains to inspect. Page context determines whether a domain deserves action.

Choose competitors from the relevant search landscape

A useful comparison starts with competitors that compete for the same audience, query set, geography, and page type. The largest companies in a sector are not always the most useful backlink comparators.

For example, a local accountancy firm may appear alongside regional firms, national directories, tax publications, and government resources for different queries. Combining all of those sites into one unlabeled competitor group can create a noisy list because each one earns links through different mechanisms.

Record why each competitor is included

The source experiment used three competing websites. Three is a manageable starting point because it allows a team to distinguish one-, two-, and three-competitor overlap without making the review set unnecessarily broad.

Before data collection, document each competitor in a simple table:

FieldExample
Competitor domainexample-competitor.com
Comparison reasonRanks for the same commercial keyword cluster
Page typeProduct and comparison pages
MarketUnited Kingdom, English language
Review date15 November 2026

Use selection rules that keep the analysis defensible:

  1. Match page intent. Compare product pages with product-page competitors and educational resources with educational competitors.
  2. Match the market. Keep countries, languages, and service areas visible in the dataset rather than assuming every link source is relevant.
  3. Match search competition. Prefer sites that repeatedly appear for the keyword cluster being targeted.
  4. Separate commercial and SERP competitors. A direct business rival may not be an organic-search rival, and both relationships can be useful when labelled clearly.
  5. Keep the set stable for each run. If competitors change, record the change so that later comparisons are not mistaken for market movement.

This preparation matters because the final output should answer a practical question: which sources reveal a realistic opportunity for this site and this campaign?

What the source workflow does and does not establish

The original post describes using Ahrefs through Monid and a coding agent to compare competitors’ referring domains, deduplicate records, count overlap, and inspect linking pages and anchors. It presents an experiment and a direction for periodic analysis, not a complete Ahrefs product or API specification.

That means a revised workflow should avoid presenting the experiment as a documented API v3 implementation. The supplied source does not establish which endpoints were called, whether data came from an export, an integration layer, browser automation, or another method, or which fields Monid made available to the coding agent.

Treat data access as a discovery task

Before building automations, a team should make an inventory of the data it can actually retrieve through its own licensed setup. For each field, record the source, level of granularity, and known limits.

RequirementEstablished by the source?Practical handling
Competitor referring domainsYes, at a workflow levelCollect and deduplicate domains for each compared site.
Number of competitors linkedYesCalculate from the deduplicated competitor-domain records.
Link anchorsYes, the author says anchors are reviewedPreserve them where the team’s setup provides them.
Linking pagesYes, the author says pages are reviewedRetain page URLs or review them manually.
Domain Rating, traffic estimates, link typeNoDo not assume availability; verify separately in the chosen tool or workflow.
First-seen and last-seen datesNoMaintain dates within the team’s own snapshot history unless verified source data is available.

This is more than a technical caveat. A report should never imply that a field is measured by the source workflow when it was added later through another tool, manual research, or internal tracking.

The core data model can remain simple. At minimum, the workflow needs a target domain, a list of competitor domains, a normalised referring domain, and an indicator showing which competitor or competitors receive links from that source.

A basic row could look like this:

referring_domainlinks_targetlinks_competitor_alinks_competitor_blinks_competitor_coverlap_count
association.example01113

In this model, overlap_count is calculated rather than imported:

overlap_count = competitor_a + competitor_b + competitor_c

Only use a value of 1 when the workflow has evidence of at least one link from that referring domain to the relevant competitor. This produces a concise domain-level comparison without overstating the number of individual backlinks.

Separate source data from team-maintained history

A production database can contain more fields, but their provenance should be explicit. For example, first_seen_in_internal_dataset is not the same thing as a provider-reported first-seen date. It simply means the team first observed the domain during one of its own recorded runs.

A practical structure is:

  • Runs: run ID, date, target, competitor set, collection method, and notes on changes.
  • Domain observations: run ID, referring domain, competitor, and whether the target already has a known link.
  • Page observations: source page URL, destination URL, anchor text, page topic, and manual-review notes, where available.
  • Prospects: deduplicated domain, placement type, review status, owner, next action, and rationale.

Fields such as authority metrics, estimated traffic, follow or nofollow status, link type, and provider-level discovery dates should be marked as optional enrichments. They may require another data source, a different report, or manual collection; they are not established by the supplied source.

Use domains to discover patterns and pages to qualify them

The source raises the right practical issue: whether to compare backlinks at domain or individual URL level. The most useful workflow uses both, at different stages.

Domain-level analysis is efficient for discovery. It shows which organisations appear repeatedly across a competitor set and makes it easier to identify common market channels such as trade bodies, publications, integration partners, review sites, community resources, or educational materials.

Page-level review is where a team decides whether a source is actionable. A domain may link to all three competitors for completely different reasons, and only the actual page reveals the context.

A two-stage review process

Stage 1: find overlap at domain level

Remove duplicate domains within each competitor’s set, calculate overlap counts, and exclude domains already known to link to the target when the goal is net-new acquisition. Keep existing domains in a separate list if the goal is link reclamation, content expansion, or relationship development.

Stage 2: inspect the page-level evidence

For high-overlap domains, examine the available linking-page records and answer:

  • What kind of page contains the competitor link?
  • Which competitor page receives it?
  • What is the apparent reason for the citation or placement?
  • Is the page live, current, and relevant to the target’s market?
  • Is there an honest route to inclusion, contribution, partnership, or citation?

A hypothetical “best inventory software” article may indicate an editorial comparison opportunity. A guest-author bio suggests a contributor relationship. A sponsorship page may require an authentic local or industry connection. A research citation may indicate that the target needs original evidence before contacting the publisher.

The goal is not to copy a backlink. It is to understand the underlying reason it exists.

Filter noise without relying on a universal metric threshold

The source author’s concern about a huge list of irrelevant domains is valid. A large export becomes less useful when ordinary directories, old press coverage, unrelated communities, and low-context placements are mixed with genuine editorial or partnership opportunities.

The first filters should be business and relevance rules, not an unexamined numeric cutoff. The supplied source does not establish available Ahrefs filters, metric definitions, or thresholds, so this workflow does not assume that a particular metric can be used in every setup.

Useful first-pass exclusions

A team can apply labels or exclusions based on page and business context:

  • Already linked: separate current link sources from net-new candidates.
  • Market mismatch: flag pages outside the client’s target country, language, or service area.
  • Topical mismatch: deprioritise sources whose audience has no meaningful relationship to the target offering.
  • User-generated or self-service sources: label profiles, forum signatures, comments, bookmarks, and similar placements separately from editorial opportunities.
  • Temporary-event coverage: distinguish funding, hiring, conference, award, or launch coverage from repeatable resource links.
  • Low-quality patterns: remove domains with autogenerated, deceptive, or clearly irrelevant pages after human review.
  • Stale pages: lower priority when a page is old, removed, or no longer maintained.

Keep the reason for each exclusion. A row marked “not relevant: Spanish-language consumer directory” is more useful than a silently deleted row because it makes the workflow auditable and prevents repeated review in future runs.

Score relevance, replicability, and effort separately

A single numerical score can be useful for sorting, but it should not hide the reason a prospect was prioritised. The source supports reviewing domains, pages, and anchors; a scoring framework is editorial guidance layered on top of that process, not a conclusion reported by the original author.

One practical model uses three scores from 0 to 5:

ScoreMeaningReview question
RelevanceAudience, topic, and market fitWould this source’s audience plausibly value the target page?
ReplicabilityEvidence of a credible placement routeIs there a legitimate path to a listing, citation, review, contribution, or partnership?
EffortWork needed to earn the placementDoes the opportunity need a small update, a relationship, or a new asset?

For a hypothetical industry directory, a target might receive relevance 5, replicability 4, and effort 2 if it clearly meets published inclusion criteria. A news article about three competitors’ acquisitions might receive relevance 3, replicability 1, and effort 5 because it is not a standard outreach opportunity.

Anchor text can strengthen the reviewer’s interpretation when it is available. Descriptive anchors pointing to competitor guides may suggest a resource need, while anchors using founder names or campaign names may point to PR-driven links. Neither pattern is proof on its own; it is evidence to combine with the page’s topic and placement type.

Turn patterns into content and relationship requirements

A strong gap analysis often produces more than a prospect list. It can reveal what competitors have published, contributed, integrated, researched, or joined in order to become citable.

Group qualified page-level examples by placement type. This creates a useful brief for content, partnerships, and PR teams.

  1. Resource pages: A target may need a more complete guide, template, tool, or glossary page before it merits inclusion.
  2. Original research: Repeated citations to competitor data may show demand for a benchmark, survey, calculator, or methodology-led study.
  3. Reviews and comparisons: Competitor inclusion may highlight product documentation, pricing clarity, trial access, or differentiation gaps.
  4. Partnership and integration pages: Links may reveal real ecosystems where the target lacks a commercial or community relationship.
  5. Association and membership pages: The correct next step may be eligibility research or an application, not cold outreach.
  6. News and PR coverage: Links may be tied to an event, product launch, or data release that requires a genuinely newsworthy alternative.

For example, if several competitors are cited in supplier roundups, the useful output is not “email every publisher.” It is a documented question: what evidence, product capability, membership status, or editorial asset would make the target a legitimate addition?

Save snapshots if the team chooses recurring analysis

The source author says they would like to run the process periodically. It does not prescribe a monthly or quarterly cadence, so any schedule should be treated as editorial operating guidance rather than a source-backed requirement.

For an active campaign, a team may choose monthly snapshots. For a stable site or a smaller market, quarterly review may be more proportionate. The key requirement is consistency: a change log only works when the team retains dated records and notes changes to its competitor set or collection method.

Maintain internal observation dates

For each competitor-domain combination, store the first and most recent run in which the team observed it. Use names such as first_seen_in_internal_dataset and last_seen_in_internal_dataset to avoid confusing internal history with provider-reported dates.

A comparison between two internal runs can surface new patterns, such as:

  • a recently observed roundup linking to two competitors;
  • a new integration ecosystem;
  • an event or award cycle generating industry coverage; or
  • a fresh competitor asset earning citations.

It can also show that a previously observed page is no longer present in the team’s collected data. That is a prompt for verification, not proof that a link was removed. Pages may be unavailable, collection methods may have changed, or the source data may be incomplete.

Automate collection and preserve human judgment

The source experiment demonstrates the value of automation for removing repetitive comparison work. Coding assistance can help normalise domains, eliminate duplicates, calculate overlap, produce review tables, and carry forward exclusions from earlier runs.

What automation should not do is decide that a publisher ought to link to a site. That decision depends on the source page, the audience, the target asset, editorial standards, and whether the proposed relationship is genuine.

A lean operational sequence is:

  1. Collect the referring-domain records available through the team’s own Monid, Ahrefs, export, or other approved setup.
  2. Normalise domains consistently, including lowercase formatting and a documented approach to subdomains.
  3. Deduplicate records within each competitor set.
  4. Calculate overlap and separate domains that already link to the target.
  5. Apply saved relevance, market, and quality labels.
  6. Retrieve or preserve available page and anchor evidence for the shortlist.
  7. Have a reviewer classify placement type, score the opportunity, and choose a next action.
  8. Save the dated output and a record of the collection method.

Before deploying this sequence, teams should test a small sample manually. If ten source rows cannot be traced to understandable pages and decisions, a larger automated export will not improve the result.

Report decisions and learning, not export size

Client and stakeholder reporting should explain what the analysis found and what will happen next. A count of candidate domains is only an input; it is not a performance outcome.

A useful report can show a transparent funnel:

  • Candidate domains: deduplicated domains linking to one or more selected competitors but not currently observed linking to the target.
  • Shared-domain candidates: domains linked to two or more competitors.
  • Reviewed pages: candidates with page-level context examined.
  • Qualified actions: opportunities assigned to outreach, content, partnerships, PR, or no action.
  • Results: placements earned, assets created, applications submitted, and lessons from declined opportunities.

Use examples only when their status is clear. For instance, a hypothetical report could state: “Four newly observed shared domains were manually reviewed. One was a relevant association directory with published eligibility criteria; the next action is to assess membership requirements. Two were old news pages and were closed with no outreach action.”

This format makes the work more credible than claiming that every competitor link is obtainable. The success measure is a progressively better understanding of where a site can earn relevant citations and links through assets, relationships, and legitimate participation.

FAQ

A competitor backlink gap analysis compares referring domains and, where available, linking pages associated with competitors against a target site’s observed link profile. It identifies sources that may represent missed citations, relationships, listings, partnerships, or editorial opportunities. A gap is a research lead, not evidence that a publisher will link to the target.

Both are useful. Referring domains help identify repeated market patterns efficiently, especially when a source links to two or three competitors. Individual URLs are needed to understand why the link exists, which competitor page it supports, whether the page is current, and whether there is an ethical, realistic route to a comparable placement.

Three closely matched competitors are a practical starting point because they make overlap easy to interpret, and the supplied source used three sites. More can be added when they share the same search landscape, page type, market, and audience. Adding unrelated domains typically increases noise and weakens the conclusions drawn from overlap.

No. A shared domain may have linked because of a funding event, contributor relationship, sponsorship, product integration, membership, review policy, or one-off news story. Review the actual page and identify a genuine reason the source might include the target. If no credible reason exists, the domain should be closed rather than pursued.

The source only suggests running the process periodically; it does not specify a cadence. As an operational choice, teams may use monthly reviews during active campaigns or quarterly reviews for stable markets. More important than frequency is retaining dated internal snapshots, a stable comparison set, and notes on any changes in collection method.

Sources